01Context & evidence
Scoping the data, and marking what is open.
One data file, one paragraph of instructions, no original script. First the agent settles what the data can estimate, and which settings are stated or open.
- Data3,246 department-year observations on 717 departments, 2012–2017, with 30 labelled variables, taken from the authors' public replication package.
- VariablesThe outcome comp is the applicant-to-hire ratio (labelled AHR); the treatment inspectmain turns 1 once a leading department is inspected. Three more variables mark the wave, or never inspected.
- Treatment and sample87 of the 119 leading departments were inspected in five cohorts, 2013–2017, giving 180 department-years after inspection. Never-inspected departments form the control group.
- Four settingsDepartment and year fixed effects (removing each one's own average), cohorts by first inspection year, never-inspected controls, and clustering by department (errors may correlate within a department).
- Open items and constraintsThree numbers and a Python script that reproduces them. No authors' script, no Stata, 30 minutes; the task does not say which column's covariates to use.
Kept in the Metacase as Goal · Evidence · Constraints
what was known at the decision point
3,246department-year observations