| ① Scope and sample · 9 points · this run 9 |
|---|
| R3 | 84 names on the authorisation list, one excluded for the wrong role, 83 in scope | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R4 | A supervisor on approved leave from week 3 of observation: restricted, outside the behaviour denominator, learning records kept | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R33 | A supervisor transferred before the first observation: likewise restricted, learning records kept | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| ② Attendance and learning time · 12 points · this run 12 |
|---|
| R5 | Effective learning time recomputed from verified attendance: a threshold of 1,377 minutes, 82 of 83 meeting it, the one below at 1,170 | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R6 | First supervisor with a missing sign-out: 360 minutes shown as pending and not counted | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R34 | Second such supervisor, same requirement | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R35 | Third such supervisor, same requirement | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| ③ Three-point tests · 9 points · this run 9 |
|---|
| R7 | 83 valid tests before and after training, 79 delayed, with the four missing supervisors named | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R8 | Formal, valid attempts only, stating that two void practice attempts are outside scores and coverage | Both | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R9 | Mean scores of about 59.1, 94.1 and 90.3, a gain of about 35.0 from before to after, each to ±0.1 | Either | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| ④ Opportunity and behaviour · 9 points · this run 6 |
|---|
| R10 | Strata by two or more verified incidents: 73 evaluable, 8 lacking opportunity, 2 outside observation; no zero or failing mark for lack of opportunity | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R11 | Behaviour attainment of 73 of 73 among the evaluable, on a mean of at least 3.0 across reviewed items | Workbook | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R12 | 1,145 observations, 1,127 reviewed and 18 pending, with the six supervisors concerned named | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| ⑤ Operational comparison and attribution · 15 points · this run 0 |
|---|
| R14 | First trained hub's change net of the deferred hub, shown directly: response-SLA rate +6.5 points, isolation completeness +8.2, repeat incidents −1.1, loss per 10,000 order lines −260 yuan | Workbook | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R15 | Second trained hub: +4.5, +5.7 and −0.7 points, −170 yuan | Workbook | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R16 | Third trained hub: +2.0, +2.7 and −0.3 points, −70 yuan | Workbook | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R17 | Net improvement not all attributed to training: the chiller repair's end date kept pending and rechecked at ±1 day, extreme-heat weeks separated or excluded, sensitive cargo stratified, the terminal-upgrade week separated | Both | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R13 | Coaching and behaviour limited to a descriptive association; the provider's remedial duties listed apart from the company's duties to provide opportunity, scheduling, coaching and review | Memo | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| ⑥ Package status and amounts · 40 points · this run 40 |
|---|
| R20 | Package A accepted conditionally, because sessions were delivered but three sign-outs are pending; not stated as fully accepted | Both | 7 | Met · +7 |
|---|
| R21 | Package B accepted in part, three of four equal evidence units | Both | 10 | Met · +10 |
|---|
| R22 | Package C accepted in part, one of two equal validation units | Both | 10 | Met · +10 |
|---|
| R23 | Package A: 220,320 yuan for approval, 24,480 retained, 0 deferred, summing to the contract amount | Both | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R24 | Package B: 275,400 yuan for approval, 91,800 deferred, 0 retained | Both | 7 | Met · +7 |
|---|
| R25 | Package C: 102,000 yuan for approval, 102,000 deferred, 0 retained | Both | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| ⑦ General: structure, status, traceability, closure · 12 points · this run 3 |
|---|
| R1 | The workbook covers 11 functions: definitions, scope check, learning path, opportunity strata, behaviour evidence, operational comparison, disruption limits, stage-gate decisions, payment split, closure tracking and a source index | Workbook | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R18 | Pending sign-outs, void practice attempts, pending incident links, observer disagreements, the repair-time gap and the provider's “uploaded” claims are not restated as verified, valid or closed | Workbook | 3 | Met · +3 |
|---|
| R19 | The source index sets up at least five chains that can be rechecked, each with its named keys and the 31 May cutoff | Workbook | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|
| R26 | The closure plan lists at least four actions, each with an owner, a deadline, closing evidence and what happens when overdue | Both | 3 | Not met · 0 |
|---|